Add "Good enough" IndieWeb Carnival blog post

This commit is contained in:
Devon Campbell 2024-03-31 21:21:53 -04:00
commit 197a3145c2
3 changed files with 46 additions and 1 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
---
title: What If "Good Enough" Is Actually Great?
layout: article.njk
date: git Last Modified
tags: post
excerpt: I make the argument that maybe "good enough" is better than we think.
---
*This is my first time participating in the [IndieWeb carnival](https://indieweb.org/indieweb-carnival). I've enjoyed working on my blog, but it very much feels like an island. I'm excited to make it part of a larger community. If you found me through this, welcome!*
The most common argument I hear for "good enough" is that the pursuit of perfect leads to less work overall, and that's a bad thing — the idea that [quantity leads to quality](https://austinkleon.com/2020/12/10/quantity-leads-to-quality-the-origin-of-a-parable/). I find this idea compelling, and it's partly why I decided to take the approach [with my video channel](/blog/im-on-youtube) of producing as much work as I can as consistently as I can at the expense of intricate production. I don't know if this is the right way, but it's the way I'm trying right now.
But as progress marches, I find an even *more* compelling argument in favor of "good enough." It may be one of our best defenses against having our monopoly on creativity destroyed. This occurred to me when a YouTube video pointed out that [many popular YouTube personalities now hold their lavalier microphones](https://youtu.be/0arvnAlV_C4). Before the video, I had *seen* this phenomenon, but I hadn't *perceived* it.
"Being held" is not the proper mode for using a lavalier microphone. They're explicitly designed *not* to be used this way. These are the style of mics that are meant to be clipped on to clothing. If you're holding one, it means, in a strictly technical sense, you done fucked up. Except these instances aren't mistakes or misunderstandings. At least, not always.
The video positions this as a reaction to a changing YouTube culture. (I'm going to spoil a lot of the video now, so if you want to hear if from the horse's mouth first, watch that and come back here when you're done.) YouTube started out as a platform for non-professionals and has evolved into the exact opposite. It's a sort of quiet act of protest to intentionally be unprofessional on a platform that has evolved to be a more professional one. It's not just an expression of dissatisfaction with the change of the culture, but it's a signal that, "I'm one of the *real* ones."
I use "real" here to mean "I'm one of the *authentic* ones," not "I'm one of the ones who exist…" but we're fast approaching a day when fucking up — whether that's intentional or whether you just make a conscious decision not to edit your work — might be a critical tool for identifying "us."
Generative AI produces work that is a brand of "perfect." We've made a lot of noise about all the factual inaccuracies it spits out, and it does spit plenty of those. What it *can* do though with great ease is present an almost perfectly *produced* output on the first iteration and in seconds full of text that is all spelled correctly and makes sense and lines that are all drawn precisely. Humans are capable of achieving the same level of perfection given a limited scope and enough time… but time is exactly what we rarely have enough of. AI effectively folds that time by learning only from our already perfected works and producing outputs based on it.
Maybe "good enough" is our best beacon to help other humans find our creative work in the sea of generated content the internet is quickly becoming. I should make an editing pass or two on this post to fix any mistakes. I should punch up this conclusion to make it more impactful. I should do these things to make this post a higher quality one… but I won't because I think you can understand my point and I think you can see that I am a human being like you. I hope that's good enough.

22
src/feed/good-enough.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
---
title: What If "Good Enough" Is Actually Great?
relativeUrl: /blog/good-enough-is-great
date: git Created
tags: feed
---
*This is my first time participating in the [IndieWeb carnival](https://indieweb.org/indieweb-carnival). I've enjoyed working on my blog, but it very much feels like an island. I'm excited to make it part of a larger community. If you found me through this, welcome!*
The most common argument I hear for "good enough" is that the pursuit of perfect leads to less work overall, and that's a bad thing — the idea that [quantity leads to quality](https://austinkleon.com/2020/12/10/quantity-leads-to-quality-the-origin-of-a-parable/). I find this idea compelling, and it's partly why I decided to take the approach [with my video channel](/blog/im-on-youtube) of producing as much work as I can as consistently as I can at the expense of intricate production. I don't know if this is the right way, but it's the way I'm trying right now.
But as progress marches, I find an even *more* compelling argument in favor of "good enough." It may be one of our best defenses against having our monopoly on creativity destroyed. This occurred to me when a YouTube video pointed out that [many popular YouTube personalities now hold their lavalier microphones](https://youtu.be/0arvnAlV_C4). Before the video, I had *seen* this phenomenon, but I hadn't *perceived* it.
"Being held" is not the proper mode for using a lavalier microphone. They're explicitly designed *not* to be used this way. These are the style of mics that are meant to be clipped on to clothing. If you're holding one, it means, in a strictly technical sense, you done fucked up. Except these instances aren't mistakes or misunderstandings. At least, not always.
The video positions this as a reaction to a changing YouTube culture. (I'm going to spoil a lot of the video now, so if you want to hear if from the horse's mouth first, watch that and come back here when you're done.) YouTube started out as a platform for non-professionals and has evolved into the exact opposite. It's a sort of quiet act of protest to intentionally be unprofessional on a platform that has evolved to be a more professional one. It's not just an expression of dissatisfaction with the change of the culture, but it's a signal that, "I'm one of the *real* ones."
I use "real" here to mean "I'm one of the *authentic* ones," not "I'm one of the ones who exist…" but we're fast approaching a day when fucking up — whether that's intentional or whether you just make a conscious decision not to edit your work — might be a critical tool for identifying "us."
Generative AI produces work that is a brand of "perfect." We've made a lot of noise about all the factual inaccuracies it spits out, and it does spit plenty of those. What it *can* do though with great ease is present an almost perfectly *produced* output on the first iteration and in seconds full of text that is all spelled correctly and makes sense and lines that are all drawn precisely. Humans are capable of achieving the same level of perfection given a limited scope and enough time… but time is exactly what we rarely have enough of. AI effectively folds that time by learning only from our already perfected works and producing outputs based on it.
Maybe "good enough" is our best beacon to help other humans find our creative work in the sea of generated content the internet is quickly becoming. I should make an editing pass or two on this post to fix any mistakes. I should punch up this conclusion to make it more impactful. I should do these things to make this post a higher quality one… but I won't because I think you can understand my point and I think you can see that I am a human being like you. I hope that's good enough.

View file

@ -7,4 +7,4 @@ date: git Last Modified
**Last updated {{ page.date | formatDatetimeForHumans }}**
I got an itch to do some videos, so I've started [a new channel on YouTube where you can learn about the video games I'm trying](/blog/im-on-youtube). Check it out and let me know what you think!
I've written my first ever post as part of the [IndieWeb carnival](https://indieweb.org/indieweb-carnival): it's about how [maybe "good enough" is actually not a bad thing](/blog/good-enough-is-great). It can help us create more, but even more importantly, it can help signal that we are human.